Explore how agentic AI transforms insurance with automation, compliance, and guardrails for scalable growth.
With generative AI becoming more mainstream, companies are starting to differentiate themselves based on whether their AI is agentic (capable of autonomous decision-making) or simply supportive. Nowhere is this distinction more important than in insurance.
As a data-heavy industry, insurance has long benefited from AI’s analytics and number-crunching strengths. But insurance is not just about numbers. It is also a people-driven business, requiring sensitive customer service for often stressed, confused, or vulnerable individuals.
On top of that, insurance operates in a legal landscape where exact wording can mean the difference between compliance and costly litigation. This unique mix of technical precision, human empathy, and legal rigor makes the insurance sector a fascinating (and challenging) case for agentic AI adoption.
Let's start with the basics. Over the last six months, the term "agentic AI" has been popping up everywhere. For example, if we look at Google Trends data, interest in the search term was nonexistent from 2004 through 2023. Then, starting in January 2024, interest surged dramatically, rapidly climbing to its highest level (100) in April 2025. In other words, "agentic AI" has recently emerged as a highly trending and prominent topic.
So, more people are Googling "agentic AI," and more recently, companies are calling their products agentic. But what exactly is agentic AI? Put simply, it is AI that can direct itself, not just respond.
Traditional AI is trained on large datasets to recognize patterns and predict outcomes. It is reactive, meaning it responds to prompts or specific inputs but does not independently pursue goals or take additional actions beyond the task. In other words, traditional AI is excellent at analyzing, generating, or summarizing information when asked, but it does not decide what to do next.
Agentic AI goes beyond that. Instead of just waiting for instructions, it can act on its own. It primarily does this through tool calling, where the AI reaches out to external software, APIs, databases, or other systems to get things done.
Rather than only working with the information it was trained on, an agentic AI can recognize what it needs, decide what tools to use, and call those tools to move a task forward. Tool calling turns AI from a passive responder into an active problem solver.
This evolution from a passive tool to a semi-autonomous agent has significant implications, especially for industries like insurance that depend on accurate information and strategic decision-making, nuanced communication, and precise execution across complex workflows.
It would work primarily by removing bottlenecks and friction across different parts of the insurance process. Let's break this down.
In a traditional setup, the system might flag the issue when something is missing from a claim, say, a key document or a signature. But it usually stops there. A human adjuster still needs to step in, track down the missing piece, and move the claim forward.
That halting to bring in a human doesn't need to happen with agentic AI. It would not only detect what's missing, but also take action. It could automatically send a request to the customer, monitor for a response, verify the returned document, and continue processing the claim without human involvement at every step. The benefit here is obvious - faster claims resolution, less manual follow-up, and a better experience for everyone involved.
Traditionally, policy changes (like updating an address or adding a new driver) require multiple handoffs. A customer submits a change, an agent reviews it, someone else recalculates the risk or premium, and another team issues the updated documents. Even simple changes can take days.
With agentic AI, that entire chain could happen seamlessly. The AI could verify the update against public records, pull updated risk information, recalculate premiums, adjust the policy terms, and automatically send out the new documents for electronic signature.
No waiting in queues. No manual data entry. Just a simple, near-instant update for the customer.
Most customer service bots today operate like fancy FAQs. They can answer basic questions but not think beyond what they’re asked. If a customer’s problem is slightly complex, the system passes them to a human agent. Customers also know this and often ask to speak to a human agent if they have a complex problem.
Agentic AI could handle this differently. For example, if a customer asked about a billing error, the AI could check payment history, spot inconsistencies, correct small issues automatically, and escalate only if necessary. Instead of just answering a question, it would resolve the problem, saving time for both the customer and the support team.
We've left this one until last because although using agentic AI in risk assessment and compliance offers huge efficiency benefits, it also requires caution.
Risk and regulation in insurance never stand still. Agentic AI could help companies keep up by monitoring real-world signals like property records, recent claims, crime rates, and new regulatory announcements. If theft reports spike in a particular area, the AI could tighten underwriting guidelines automatically. If a new law affects policy language, it could flag the right sections for review and even draft suggested updates.
Of course, human oversight will always be preferred and sometimes even required in this area. Legal mishaps cost insurance companies far more than operational delays ever could.
An agentic AI can spot changes and suggest updates quickly, but final decisions about policy language, regulatory compliance, and customer communication still need a human eye. In risk and compliance, speed is valuable, but getting it right is essential.
If agentic AI promises to remove bottlenecks and accelerate insurance operations, why not let it run free? The answer is simple: insurance is a highly regulated, high-stakes industry where small mistakes can have big consequences. That's why building strong guardrails around agentic AI systems is not optional; it's essential.
Here, guardrails mean clear limits on what the AI can do, where it can act independently, and when it must hand control back to a human. Good guardrails involve setting boundaries on actions, requiring human review at key decision points, and ensuring that every step the AI takes is transparent and auditable.
Without these controls, the risks are enormous. A fully autonomous AI could accidentally deny valid claims, misinterpret regulations, expose sensitive customer data, or even open a company to fines and lawsuits. Even one bad decision could cause serious reputational and financial damage in a business built on customer trust and legal compliance.
Insurance is unlike e-commerce or entertainment, where a wrong product suggestion or a mistargeted ad is easily forgiven. Here, words matter. Timelines matter. People's lives and livelihoods are often on the line. Building in smart, proactive guardrails ensures that agentic AI delivers on its promise of speed and efficiency, without sacrificing the precision, fairness, and accountability that the industry demands.
If guardrails are critical for agentic AI, what should they look like in practice?
Agentic AI can handle heavy lifting, but humans should still make the final call on high-stakes actions. For example, an AI might prepare a claim denial based on missing documentation, but a human should review and approve it before it goes out to the customer.
Just because AI can call external tools doesn’t mean it should have free rein. Good guardrails limit which systems an agentic AI can access and what actions it can trigger. For example, it might pull customer data or generate draft communications, but it should not initiate payments or policy cancellations without approval.
Mistakes happen, even with sophisticated AI. Systems should be able to detect when an error occurs, alert a human operator, and roll back or freeze actions if needed. This helps prevent small issues from turning into bigger, costlier problems.
Every action an agentic AI takes should be logged, traceable, and easily reviewed. Continuous monitoring ensures that the AI stays within its intended boundaries and gives insurers the evidence they need for internal audits or regulatory reviews.
The point of guardrails is not to hold AI back. It's to create a foundation where agentic AI can move faster, act independently, and take on more complex tasks without introducing unacceptable risks to the business or the customer. In other words, good guardrails turn autonomy into a competitive advantage, not a liability.
Insurance has always been a people-heavy business. Growth usually means hiring more claims adjusters, customer service representatives, and back-office staff to handle the volume. It works—up to a point. Eventually, adding more people becomes expensive, slow, and difficult to manage.
Agentic AI offers another path. Instead of scaling by headcount, companies can scale by capability. AI can pick up many of the smaller, routine decisions that slow teams down, keep claims moving, handle policy changes, and anticipate customer needs without constant direction. That frees human staff to focus on the harder problems that require judgment and expertise.
This is not just about cutting costs. It is about building a business that can handle more customers, complexity, and change without falling behind. Growth stops being limited by the number of people you can hire and starts being driven by how intelligently you can run it.
As powerful as agentic AI can be, it introduces new security challenges that insurers must take seriously. Here's where the biggest risks lie:
Every external tool an agentic AI can access becomes a potential entry point for attackers. Without strong controls, malicious actors could manipulate the AI into making unauthorized calls or leaking sensitive information.
Agentic AI pulls in real-time customer data, policy details, and financial information. Without strict access controls and encryption, private data is more likely to be accidentally shared or stolen.
If an AI is compromised or poorly monitored, it could call unauthorized tools, trigger fake transactions, or manipulate backend systems. Guarding against this requires tight validation and permissions at every step.
Agentic AI systems must be built with identity verification and permission management baked in, not added as an afterthought. Every AI action should be tied to authenticated credentials and limited by role-based permissions.
Insurers must maintain clear, tamper-proof logs of every tool the AI calls, every action it takes, and every data it accesses. Real-time anomaly detection helps catch unusual behavior before it becomes a breach.
Security cannot be an afterthought. For agentic AI to succeed in insurance, it must be trusted, and that trust is built on visible and resilient security foundations.
Agentic AI has the potential to transform insurance, but realizing that potential takes more than technology. It demands strong guardrails, thoughtful design, and a clear balance between automation and human judgment. Done right, agentic AI will not just make insurance faster or cheaper — it will make it smarter, safer, and more resilient.
At BP3, we are experts in AI consulting. We help companies enhance business AI with secure, scalable solutions built for real-world complexity. If you are thinking about bringing agentic AI into your organization, we can help you build it the right way, with speed, trust, and results at the center.
Explore how AI transforms risk assessment, claims processing, and fraud detection in insurance, driving precision and speed.
Discover how AI enhances finance with automation, anomaly detection, NLP, and analytics to boost precision and efficiency.
See STHK NHS Trust's automation journey for enhanced patient care & back-office efficiency, with significant time savings & improved service delivery.
Subscribe to our newsletter